The Plaza, A Fairmont Managed Hotel
by the TopOfHotel team
The Plaza is a night inside the building that has been the face of New York for over a century — a Central Park corner location nothing else can match, with gold and crystal fittings throughout, traded against some room types that run compact for the price.
The Plaza is a night inside the building that has been the face of New York for over a century — a Central Park corner location nothing else can match, with gold and crystal fittings throughout, traded against some room types that run compact for the price.
In-Depth Review
Rooms and decor
Picture a white, castle-shaped French Renaissance building that has stood on the corner of Central Park since 1907 — that is The Plaza, maybe the most iconic hotel in New York. It went through a major renovation in 2008 but kept its classic spirit intact. Step into a room and you meet that old-European luxury: high ceilings, chandeliers, heavy drapes, and a cream-and-gold palette that feels warm and grand. The real signature is the marble bathroom with its 24K gold fittings, gleaming gold taps, a soaking tub, and premium toiletries. Plenty of reviewers say the detailing lives up to the name. Beds are soft and dressed in good-quality linens, and some higher-category rooms open onto views of green Central Park or the buzz of Fifth Avenue. If you love a luxury that comes with a story — serious, classic, not minimalist-modern — this is heaven.
Food and amenities
The heart of The Plaza is Palm Court, the famous hall under a stained-glass dome that has served legendary afternoon tea for over a century — hot tea in pretty porcelain, scones, tiny sandwiches, and sweets arranged on a three-tier stand among palm trees and marble columns. For many people this is the whole reason to come. Head down to the basement and you reach The Plaza Food Hall, a collection of food stalls and good eats at friendlier prices than the main restaurant, ideal for a casual meal during the day. For cocktails there is The Rose Club, a classic bar to settle into in the evening. There is also a spa and fitness center to unwind after a day of walking, and suite guests get a butler on hand. The doormen in classic uniforms out front are part of the picture that makes you feel you are stepping into another era.
Location and getting there
Location is the trump card no other New York hotel can match. The Plaza sits right on the corner of Fifth Avenue and Central Park South — cross the street and you are in Central Park, Manhattan's green lung, for a walk, a bike ride, or a horse-carriage loop. The other side is Fifth Avenue, the world's most expensive shopping street, lined with designer boutiques and the legendary Bergdorf Goodman. The 5 Av/59 St subway station (N/R/W lines) is only about a 2-minute walk, so hopping a train to any part of the city is easy. MoMA is a few minutes on foot, and the bright lights of Times Square are an easy stroll. The short version: if you want to wake up and walk in Central Park in the morning, shop Fifth Avenue in the afternoon, then come back for tea at Palm Court, this location nails it.
Things to know before booking
Straight talk to help you decide — the gripe that comes up most is room size, especially the entry-level rooms, which some reviewers feel run compact for this price. Because it is an old 1907 building, the layouts are not as roomy as newer luxury hotels built later. If you want space and a full park view, upgrade to a higher category and say so clearly when you book. The other thing that catches people out is a Destination Fee added per night on top of the room rate, so check the full total when you book so the final bill does not surprise you. On top of that, as a famous landmark, the lobby, Palm Court, and Food Hall see tourists and photographers coming and going constantly, and it gets busy at times. Anyone expecting the quiet privacy of a small boutique hotel may need to make peace with the bustle.
Our take
After reading through hundreds of real reviews, The Plaza earns its name on a legendary Central Park corner location, renowned icon status, and a classic luxury atmosphere that newer hotels cannot copy. If your mental picture of the trip is a morning walk in Central Park, an afternoon shopping Fifth Avenue, then afternoon tea under the stained-glass dome of Palm Court, this is the most fitting choice and a memory of New York that is hard to forget. But if you value a spacious, modern room or quiet privacy above all else, the compact room sizes and the busy lobby may leave you feeling there are better fits. Overall we give it 8.9/10 — best for couples, families, and luxury travelers who want to sleep inside a historic landmark in the middle of Manhattan.
Score Breakdown
Assessed by our editorial team from data and real guest reviews
The Honest Verdict — pros & what to know
- A legendary location on the corner of Fifth Avenue and Central Park South — cross the street and you are in Central Park, and the subway is about a 2-minute walk away.
- A historic 1907 French Renaissance building registered as a landmark, with a classic grand feel that newer hotels simply cannot fake.
- Palm Court, under its stained-glass dome, is the home of New York's legendary afternoon tea — and plenty of people come to The Plaza specifically for it.
- Rooms are dressed in real luxury, with 24K gold bathroom fittings, marble soaking tubs, and premium toiletries, and reviewers praise the detailing as worth the price.
- Service that many reviewers call warm and attentive, from butlers for the suites to doormen in classic uniforms and a concierge that can sort out a whole trip.
- Some room types, especially the entry-level ones, run more compact than you would expect at this price. Because this is an old 1907 building, the floor plans are not as roomy as newer luxury hotels built later, and some reviewers feel the space is tight.
- There is a Destination Fee added per night on top of the room rate. Check the full total carefully when you book so the final bill does not surprise you.
- As a famous landmark, it draws plenty of tourists and people stopping to take photos. The lobby and Food Hall can get busy at times, so anyone expecting the quiet privacy of a small boutique hotel may need to make peace with the bustle.
Who It’s For
Match Score by travel style
Amenities
Location & Nearby Spots
Things to do near New York City
Day tours, attraction tickets and experiences around New York City — book ahead on Klook with mobile e-tickets.
See activities in New York CityAffiliate link — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Insider Tips
- If you want a full Central Park or Fifth Avenue view, say so when you book and choose a higher room category, since many rooms face the building's interior or the side street.
- Afternoon tea at Palm Court is very popular and seats fill fast, so book several days ahead, especially on weekends and around the holidays.
- Head down to The Plaza Food Hall in the basement for good food at friendlier prices than the main restaurant — ideal for a casual meal during the day.